“But if I’m not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?”

,,Peripeţiile Alisei în Ţara Minunilor", Romanian translation of Carroll's book by Frida Papadache (Editura Tineretului, 1965). Illustrations by Mabel Lucie Attwell
,,Peripeţiile Alisei în Ţara Minunilor”, Romanian translation of Carroll’s book by Frida Papadache (Editura Tineretului, 1965). Illustrations by Mabel Lucie Attwell

Ah, here it comes then, finally, a proper blog post. Many of you will probably recognise that title quotation as lifted whole out of one of the most famous books in the world, Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. That’s when Alice, frustrated and confused by so many (rather brusque) changes in height, and puzzled by the anthropomorphic White Rabbit who stubbornly refuses to acknowledge her in his haste , begins to doubt her own identity. And that’s one of the things that have always stuck with me – the mystery of this little girl’s identity: who is she, actually, and what makes her who she is, and, more importantly, why is that important at all? And since these are all questions which I should be addressing, like, right now, in a thesis chapter that seems to be infinitely writing itself in my mind (though sadly not on paper), I have, of course, decided to procrastinate by way of a timely blog post.

As I just said, the – often – inscrutable Alice and her ‘muchness’ have obsessed me since time immemorial. No, actually, only since the age of 7, when I stumbled upon a gorgeously illustrated Romanian edition of Alice in Wonderland at the house of a relative. Naturally, I first fell in love with the attractive cover and the beautiful illustrations I then discovered within. (Love for the text itself soon followed cue, but that’s another story.) In fact, I loved the book so much, that the two of us became inseparable and the relative in question – in whose library I found the book – eventually let me have it as a present. (All of this much to my mother’s horror, who found Alice ‘utterly absurd’ and couldn’t understand my sudden fixation.) Well, I have no idea where that particular book ended up (I’m sure it’s still back home,

,,Peripeţiile Alisei în Ţara Minunilor", translation by Frida Papadache (Editura Ion Creangă, 1976). Illustrations by Angi Petrescu-Tipărescu
,,Peripeţiile Alisei în Ţara Minunilor”, translation by Frida Papadache (Editura Ion Creangă, 1976). Illustrations by Angi Petrescu-Tipărescu

somewhere), but I could never forget the spell its soft-coloured illustrations cast on me. For a long time I thought they were drawn either by a Romanian or a Russian illustrator (seeing how old that edition was, I found it rather probable that it might have been illustrated by an artist from the Soviet Bloc). However, just today, as I was perusing this Flavorwire article on the evolution of Alice in Wonderland cover designs over time, I found that actually, the beautiful illustrations I knew and loved were all drawn by Mabel Lucie Attwell (1879-1964), who made them for a 1910 British edition of the book. (You can admire them all, in all their cute/uncanny glory, here.) This late realisation made me look up some actual Romanian illustrations for the Alice book from back in the day; I was really curious to see how these compared to Western representations of Alice. I managed to dig out two sets, one from a 1976 edition illustrated by Angi Petrescu-Tipărescu, and the other from a 1987 edition illustrated by Vasile Olac. In fact, I even own a copy of the former, and I previously photographed and posted the illustrations on this very blog (that post is long since gone, because the website that used to host the images has ‘left the web’). So here they are; I’m sharing them all with you. I hope that one day, someone will build a great online archive of all the Alice illustrations ever made all over the world. (The Romanian ones that I promised are under the cut. Caution for everyone with a slow connection: this will be VERY image-heavy!)

The 1976 illustrations by Angi Petrescu-Tipărescu.

First of all, apologies for the bad quality of these. I recently found them in a computer folder, where I had (some two or three years ago) deposited them for safekeeping. These are not scans, but photos, taken with a camera under very bad light conditions. I haven’t had an opportunity to do some decent scans of the pics in question, but when I do get the chance, I’ll come back and replace them. For the moment, I’m afraid the bad photos will have to do…

I found Petrescu-Tipărescu’s illustrations quite surreal (actually, you could even say the colourful cover design was rather trippy), with that insistence on drawing (creepy) starry eyes, on stylising the animals and making everything (hair, feathers, bunny ears) look as though it was waving in the wind. I have to confess I particularly liked what I see as the ‘Oriental design’ touches: the ‘wrought iron’ lamps, intricately ‘carved’ doors, the arabesque on the Mad Hatter’s teapot… However, I also couldn’t help but notice the striking similarities between Petrescu-Tipărescu’s Alice and Attwell’s Alice (see the dotty drop-waist dress? the stripy stockings? the wavy, beribboned hairdo?) and some Soviet-style elements (the backdrop sun meant to emphasise the ‘brilliancy’ of the main character?).

The 1987 illustrations by Vasile Olac.

These ones I lifted from some book scans helpfully uploaded online by a kind soul. Thank you, whoever you are!

This, as you probably noticed, was a particularly lavish edition, with full colour illustrations virtually every two pages. But well, if Petrescu-Tipărescu’s illustrations were rather surreal, then Olac’s are downright eerie. Where do I even start? His Alice is the ‘Aryan type’ (blonde and blue-eyed, as well one might expect, I suppose; after all, even Tenniel’s famous representations show us a fair little girl) wearing a subdued schoolgirl hairdo and a scrubbed white collar. Interestingly, also, she is androgynous (in the first illustration, I initially thought she was a boy) – with her long, shapeless yellow dress (which might as well be a nightgown). Another androgynous figure is the Mock Turtle, whom I at first had some difficulty in understanding whether it was modelled after a wrinkled old woman or a bald old man. And there is so much stuff added to Olac’s illustration (by comparison with the text), that I feel quite confident the pictures tell us a story that is definitely not Carroll’s. Seriously, while looking at the illustration (in the actual text), half of the time it was difficult to even say what they were all about. I mean, where does the ‘Father Time’ guy come from? Or the two figures painting sheets of paper with treacle at the tea party? Or the arrows in the gardeners’ hats? Or the green, insectile man peeping at Alice and the Mad Hatter et al from behind the trees??? Olac’s Wonderland is populated by wonderful, bizarre, monstrous creatures which I believe not even Carroll ever dreamed of! His illustrations at times put me in mind of the macabre art of Edward Gorey or funny/weird stuff of Tim Burton. I don’t understand where it comes from, and it makes my heart skip a beat to look at it.

1977 Romanian children's magazine, picturing pupils of various ages dressed in school uniforms characteristic of the era
1977 Romanian children’s magazine, picturing pupils of various ages dressed in school uniforms characteristic to the period

I’d be more than happy to read your thoughts on these unusual illustrations – how do you read them? Do they remind you of anything? Do you find them in any way propagandistic? Or perhaps seditious? Do let me know!

Finally, I’d like to pass this ‘quest’ on to you, international readers: do you know of any wonderful and obscure representations of Alice? By artists from your home countries, perhaps? Please do share if you can, I’d love see as many overlooked Alice illustrations as possible!

Advertisements

One thought on ““But if I’m not the same, the next question is, Who in the world am I?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s